Producer Fran Ashcroft: How many tracks are enough?
One of the most enduring myths in recording has been the endless quest for more and more tracks, which grew exponentially from the real need to overdub in the 60's. Prior to 4 track, overdubs were made by compiling sounds from one machine to another - with a generation loss of sonics every time...
Follow RecordProducer.com on Twitter...
by Fran Ashcroft
One of the most enduring myths in recording has been the endless quest for more and more tracks, which grew exponentially from the real need to overdub in the 60's. Prior to 4 track, overdubs were made by compiling sounds from one machine to another - with a generation loss of sonics every time. Added to the noise floor issues inherent in analog, and no noise reduction methods available, options were very limited, even with 4 track, especially after the release Sgt. Pepper, when the recording itself became the art form, rather than the live performance.
The introduction of 8-track allowed flexibility for alternate vocals takes, solos, etc that hadn't been possible before, and in turn 16/24 track opened the door for using a separate track for every instrument, and in more recent times, every component of the instrument with multiple microphones, and every effect on each component on every track. In stereo.
Now, we have a limitless number of tracks - and it really is essential to give serious thought as to how many are practical. It is senseless to record 40 tracks of vocals and comp them into a 'performance'. There's no question that a single track with a real, emotive vocal will always be more effective. Apply that thinking to all aspects of a recording, and the amount of tracks anyone could ever need shrinks dramatically. As a bonus, fewer tracks make for more manageable, dynamic mixes, and recordings with a more realistic feel and emotiveness.
When I set up Happybeat Studio, I'll admit taking this philosophy to the extreme. I'd never worked on 4 track in its heyday, and many of the records I admired most were done on that format. It is a challenging one, which requires a lot of forethought, and very effective arrangements to work well. After recording for 20 years, I finally felt up to the task, and got myself a 4 track Minidisc. Out of all the digital media of the time, it was most akin to analog in its operation - pretty much press record and go necessary, as I have little patience with scrolling through menus or working with a mouse instead of faders.
The Minidisc allowed me to submix and overdub quite like the old days - and therefore focus on the most important tasks of visualizing the finished record with all its constituent parts before starting out. When you're printing reverbs, EQs, pans and balances to a submix bounce, you have to allow room to position everything that will be added later to the final mix picture. You can't postpone decisions until mixing, or recall and fix anything, so it does require using your ears to the max. Naturally, 4 track is not suitable for everything or everyone, and I use Pro Tools, Cubase, etc like everyone else. But I always approach it in the same economical way with enough pre-production, to distill all those endless options into a workable platform, and preserve a natural, musical quality to the results.
Contact Fran Ashcroft for recording, mixing, mentoring for aspiring recordists, and A&R input on new projects.
Email: happybeatstudios@yahoo.co.uk
Website: www.happybeat.net
Publication date Thursday May 13, 2010
(You can unsubscribe quickly and easily.)
Discussion on this article's topic...
Tuesday May 25, 2010
Monday May 24, 2010
During a recent conversation with a lecturer in multi media, the subject of my profound aversion to the computer takeover of video editing (which is essentially a tactile event) came up. He grinned and said "I've got loads of students who know the software back to front but none of the b*****s can edit. They're so tech headed all they can do is clever software tricks and have no 'feel', sense of timing or ability to truly create."
Maybe it would do us all good to get back to basics. Having worked in creative fields most of my life prior to becoming a cripple (it was not a career choice), I am ever aware that a ten year old child can make you look a complete fool by seeing through all the 'systems' and 'strategies' and 'devices' straight to the simple heart of the matter with eyes unclouded by years of producing ever more complex solutions.
Murphy's Law adaption: Mess (read Track Count) expands to fill the space available.
Chris
Wednesday May 19, 2010
Monday May 17, 2010
Saturday May 15, 2010
Saturday May 15, 2010
Friday May 14, 2010
For example: With Protocols and other such recording devices, you can record the entire secession, while at home, or wherever you so choose. Then take the product into a studio, saving hundreds of dollars on recording, mixing, etc. I am not saying you need lots of tracks in order to make a good recording, only that there is only so much one can create with four, or even eight tracks. As a producer, songwriter, today you want unlimited possibilities. Recording groups back in the day would have died for Pro Tools, etc/100, or more tracks.
Friday May 14, 2010
UPDATE - Posting of comments has been disabled. RecordProducer.com has been targeted by a botnet posting spam comments. The facility to post comments will return when this problem has been resolved.
We welcome your addition to the discussion on the topic of this article. If you feel that the article is inaccurate in any way, please let us know by e-mail at . We read all messages sent to this address but we cannot promise a reply.
 |
Leaving aside questions of color and pattern, what type of carpet works best in a recording studio environment? Read more... |
 |
In contrast to my recent article where I said that choice of microphone often doesn't matter, there are times where selecting the right microphone can make an enormous difference to your sound. Read more... |
 |
Mike Leader of Leader Cinema systems, manufacturers of world class large-scale systems for both music industry and motion picture industry professionals, tells you more about subwoofers than you thought you could possibly want to know... Read more... |
 |
A good drummer is worth his or her weight in platinum. But how can you know for sure just how good they are? Read more... |
 |
Jamhub is a totally new concept - a rehearsal amp for the whole band. RecordProducer.com asks inventor Steve Skillings all about Jamhub - what it does, where the idea came from, and why you should want one. (There's a prize too!) Read more... |
 |
The range of great home recording equipment available these days is truly superb. But occasionally we all buy something that just wasn't worth the money. What's your experience? Read more... |
 |
Do you always connect your effects pedals between your guitar and amplifier. Wow, that's just so retro! Read more... |
 |
For performance, the soloists stand in front of the choir. But for recording, perhaps they should stand behind. Here's why... Read more... |
 |
An RP visitor enquires whether the Genelec 8240A with digital inputs and DSP is suitable for the home recording studio. Hmm... Read more... |
 |
A record label specializing in high quality audio charges $$$ for its tracks. But will you get good value for your money? Read more... |
 |
Still struggling to get a good sound in your home recording studio? Perhaps a visit to a pro studio would fix all your problems. Read more... |
 |
Both EQ and filters alter the frequency response characteristics of a signal. But how are they different, and how should they be applied? Read more... |
 |
It was supposed to be a magical and revolutionary device. But now that it's here, it is plain that it really isn't anything special at all. Read more... |
 |
If your drum reverbs are hanging around too long, they could be confusing your sound. How long should a drum reverb last? Read more... |
 |
'If you don't ask, you don't get!' That's a good old proverb. But have you asked anyone recently? This guy has... Read more... |
 |
Anyone still using pre-2005 software? Pre-2000?? Pre-1995??? Can anyone go back even further than that? Read more... |
 |
An RP reader asks whether he can record on his workstation and then export tracks to his computer for editing and mixing. Why would he want to do that...? Read more... |
 |
Apple's launch of the iPad has created a whole new segment in computing. Should musicians rejoice? Or be very afraid? Read more... |
 |
Ah, that mysterious Q control in your EQ. Does it actually do anything? Read more... |
 |
Some microphone and instrument preamplifiers have a variable impedance selector. What kind of difference will it make to your sound? What are you missing if you don't have it? Read more... |
